About a Lot More Than the iPhone

The Library of Congress, which has the power to create exemptions to the DMCA, has has made just released very significant carve outs, though to read the New York Times, it's all about the iPhone.

You see, two of the things that are now allowed under the ruling are software to "jailbreak" the iPhone, both to allow non-Apple^™ App Store applications, and to use the iPhone on a non AT&T networks.

Actually, this applies to all cell phones, but this is not a big deal.

What you also have is:

• The right to rip short videos from DVDs for the educational and criticism purposes.
• Defeating video game encryption for, "The purpose of good faith testing for, investigating, or correcting security flaws or vulnerabilities".
• Circumventing dongles when they become obsolete or exit manufacture.
• Allowing circumvention of technical measures on E-Books to allow them to be read aloud.

This is stunning. It is consumer friendly, good policy, and common sense.

I would never have expected any of the three things to happen with the US copyright establishment.

I must therefore assume that this was as a result of input from political appointees in the USPTO and Library of Congress, this is fairly radical for career bureaucrats, and as such we need to give the White House credit.

I will note that there is still a work around that Apple^™ could use which would make non App Store applications illegal, by using the Sega strategy, which involved using a verification key (the letters S-E-G-A) which would load the banner message, "PRODUCED BY OR UNDER LICENSE FROM SEGA ENTERPRISES LTD," before the program loaded (thanks for the legal research from DC at SP), which made jail-breaking the console a trademark violation.

I don't see Apple^™ doing this, I think that it would unleash regulatory and customer blow-back, but the legal precedent remains there.

Link to the official anti-circumvention rule-making.